SC reserves order on re-appointment of Calcutta University vice-chancellor – India Today

Kolkata News

The Supreme Court on Friday reserved its judgment on the plea of the West Bengal government against the Calcutta High Court order that set aside the re-appointment of the vice-chancellor of Calcutta University.

A bench of Justices DY Chandrachud and Hima Kohli reserved the judgment after hearing Senior Advocate AM Singhvi that the High Court passed the order and set aside the decision of the statutory authority.

READ Why Bengal governor Jagdeep Dhankhar is upset with Mamata over VC appointments

At the outset, Senior Advocate Singhvi said the HC order was passed after the verdict was reserved for several months.

Justice Chandrachud responded, “Two months is not a long time for reserving judgment. Tell us, does the government have the power to re-appoint VCs?”

Singhvi replied, “Under Section 8 of the Calcutta University Act. Kindly have a look at provision 8(2).”

At this, the bench asked, “Who had the original power under Section 8(2)? After the amendment what is the change that is brought about? The original power given to the Chancellor is not substituted by the amendment.”

ALSO READ Bengal govt to amend law to make CM Mamata Banerjee chancellor of state-run varsities

Singhvi submitted that, “The intention of amendment to Section 8(2) (a) is that the power vesting in the Chancellor is taken away in favour of the state government. Change of intent in the amendment is not dealt with by the Judge.”

But the bench said, “One thing that is bothering us is Section 8(2) (a) does not specifically say who will appoint. What is the consequence of satisfaction that they become eligible for appointment? Is that an indicator that the appointment power is still with the Chancellor? Such a badly drafted amendment. Your client amended it to take over the power of the Chancellor, but it is badly drafted.”

Senior Advocate Ranjit Kumar appearing for the respondent said, “The relevant UGC regulations, 2018, also require the appointment to be made by the Chancellor. So, the Chancellor is not making a decision, but the Chancellor cannot be bypassed.”

READ MORE Kerala Governor seeks explanation from Kannur VC on appointment of CPI(M) leader’s wife

On September 13, the Calcutta High Court set aside the re-appointment of Sonali Chakravarti Banerjee as vice-chancellor of Calcutta University, holding that the West Bengal government has no authority to do so as per provisions of the varsity’s Act.

The high court had ordered that the state had no authority to appoint or reappoint the vice-chancellor either under Section 8 of the Calcutta University Act or by taking recourse to residuary Section 60 of the Act.

Banerjee was appointed vice-chancellor of Calcutta University on August 28, 2017, for four years and her term expired on August 27, 2021. Thereafter, a notification was issued under the signature of the special secretary of the West Bengal government’s Higher Education Department, whereby Banerjee was reappointed vice-chancellor of Calcutta University with effect from August 28, 2021, for four years.

— ENDS —

Source: https://www.indiatoday.in/law/story/sc-reserves-order-on-reappointment-of-calcutta-university-vice-chancellor-2001436-2022-09-17